In just a little more than a month I’ll be moving into my new house. I’ve been thinking quite a bit about whether or not we’ll pay for a cable TV subscription. Here is my current TV consumption:
- Sportscenter (Cable)
- Basketball and football games and other major sporting events (Mostly on Network TV and ESPN which is Cable)
- The Office (Network TV)
I will occasionally watch another program if I’m flipping through channels during dinner or something like that, but nothing that I would mind missing. I’ve decided that I’d like to cut down on the amount of sports I watch because there are really only a handful of games in each major sport that matter throughout the year so watching Sportscenter on an almost everyday basis probably is not necessary. However, not being able to watch the College Basketball National Championship game when my Tar Heels are playing would be pretty discouraging.
With March Madness starting today I’m amazed at the high quality, yet fast and responsive video that CBSsports.com is able to deliver on all of the tournament games. I know Hulu and other sites have great video and ESPN has video on demand that you can pay for, but the value that CBS provides by streaming every single game online is unprecendented. The NCAA tournament is perfect for internet consumption because it allows you to switch between multiple games at once at your own discretion. You don’t have to let the TV network decide what game is best for your area to watch because you’re in control. It’s clear that this type of video streaming is entirely possible, and it makes me wonder why ESPN or other networks don’t provide more of their content this way. My thought was that more of this kid of content would become available online and I could catch most of the shows that I wanted online. The hurdle clearly comes down to money and the fact that monetization online is much more difficult.
I got a tip on Twitter that I should check out some of Mark Cuban’s thought on this issue. He’s pretty knowledgeable in this area considering he founded Broadcast.com and had a big part in HD TV. It turns out that he has several blog posts on TV content on his blog that were extremely informative. I’d suggest you read what we has to say (rather than my quick summary) in these posts – Don’t Waste the Internet on TV – Protect the Future of the Internet and Senator Al Franken is Requesting User Caps on Internet Bandwidth?
Basically, Cuban is saying that there are a lot of bandwidth costs that go along with putting more and more video on the internet. It’s not a simple question of whether networks can generate ad revenue off of the content, but the physical infrastructure of the networks of internet service providers would have to be significantly upgraded if everyone just started watching all of their regular TV content online. Then monthly internet subscription rates would have to increase considerably, and then there’s not really much of an advantage of watching TV on your computer anymore. Cuban is fairly pessimistic about TV content online because the internet is simply not designed to handle it well.
To switch gears for a minute, I’m also taking into consideration the words of wisdom on watching TV from marketing guru Seth Godin. His recent post on TV was pretty eye-opening. Seth argues that there are an infinite number of things that you could be spending your time on that’s better than TV. Some of his ideas were:
- Write a daily blog
- Start an online community about your favorite passion
- Go to meetups in your town
- Volunteer to tutor a kid, in person or online
- Produce small films and publish them online
- Read a book or two every evening
- Play a game of Scrabble with your family
I had trouble trimming this list down because all of Godin’s ideas are superb, and clearly all much better than watching 3 hours of TV. By giving up TV I’d be freeing up my time for more of the things that I’d really like to be doing, but sometimes end up on the backburner because I don’t always have enough time. Seth’s ideas are pretty inspiring because he says the things you know are 100% true, but sometimes you can’t quite motivate yourself to do them.
Ultimately, I think I’m going to wait on getting a cable subscription at least for a little while when I move into my new house. Internet is non-negotiable so that will definitely be installed soon (although I can get by for a few days with just my Droid). If we realize we really want TV then we’ll go ahead with it, but it’s not going to be a given.
What do you think? Could you do without a cable subscription?